NaturalPedia > Evidence-based Medicine

Quotes about Evidence-based Medicine from the world's top natural health / natural living authors

 Email this page to a friend   |  Click here for FREE email alerts

page 1 of 3 | Next ->

"Or rather we should say that evidence-based medicine has dismissed both psychoanalysis and cognitive therapy. The former was abandoned some time ago; as for the latter, meta-analysis has demonstrated that it does not "confer reliable benefits for patients with schizophrenia and cannot be recommended for clinical practice.46 Recall David Rosenhan's experiment. Were it repeated today, his pseudo-patients would surely be treated with drugs (as would Job!), either "neuroleptics," or "atypical antipsychotics." - Gerald E. Markle and Frances B. McCrea, What If Medicine Disappeared? (Get the book.)

"We call this evidence-based medicine. But as the last two chapters show, there are not that many treatments available for chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), fibromyalgia (FM), and the other illnesses we've been discussing. So how can I promise to help every patient who walks into my office? I have my own golden rule that trumps the golden rule of medicine: I can always do something to help, so I never tell a patient the situation is hopeless. Traditional Western medical techniques fall under the heading of allopathic medicine, and serve us well as far as they go." - Benjamin H. Natelson, M.D., Your Symptoms Are Real: What to Do When Your Doctor Says Nothing Is Wrong (Get the book.) "But then I told you that I continue to try it on patients anyway, which is contrary to the rules of evidence-based medicine I have tried to share with you throughout this book. I break my own rule for two reasons: I am quite positive the drug helps some people (this seemed to be the case for several of the smaller sites in the multicenter trial I headed), and modafinil happens to be a drug we can try within the standard of the Natelson Six-Week Rule. If it fails to have an effect, we'll know it within six weeks." - Benjamin H. Natelson, M.D., Your Symptoms Are Real: What to Do When Your Doctor Says Nothing Is Wrong (Get the book.)

"Evidence Grade In keeping with the current trend in evidence-based medicine, an evidence grade has been assigned to the orthomolecular treatments reviewed in this book. These evidence-based summaries are not meant to provide an exhaustive account of all relevant sources. Rather, only those articles pertaining to anxiety or related psychiatric conditions involving orthomolecular treatments will be assigned evidence grades. These evidence grades are based on the hierarchy of evidence developed by the Oxford Centre for evidence-based medicine (Table n)." - Dr. Jonathan Prousky, BPHE, BSc, ND, FRSH, Anxiety: Orthomolecular Diagnosis and Treatment (Get the book.)

"Phrases like "the integrity of evidence-based medicine" came to mind. But what was the point, aside from further alienating her colleagues and leading the student toward a nervous breakdown? Religious beliefs are particularly resistant to proof. "That's all the questions I have," Fran murmured, studying her notes carefully." - Gerald E. Markle and Frances B. McCrea, What If Medicine Disappeared? (Get the book.) "Once again, the cardiologist eschews evidence-based medicine. Finally, the facilities exist for prompt and aggressive surgery, therefore it can and will happen. "That last point is like saying: 'If you build it, they will come,'" I concluded. As an editorial in the prestigious British medical journal, Lancet, concludes—with typically English humor: "Stents clearly have a great future—they give excellent predictive results in angiography, are clinically safe, and most of all, calm the interventional cardiologist."21 "Finally, something I can agree with," proclaimed Fran. " - Gerald E. Markle and Frances B. McCrea, What If Medicine Disappeared? (Get the book.)

"It is estimated that some 10,000 reviews are necessary to provide a comprehensive "evidence-based medicine" library with periodic updating of all reviews (Mallett and Clarke 2003). There is much work to do, particularly since the available reviews (and probably the available rcts) do not reflect the global burden of disease (Swingler et al. 2003). To date, the Cochrane Collaboration has shunned support from pharmaceutical firms and the like, although individual reviewers are not restricted in that regard." - Nortin M. Hadler MD, Worried Sick: A Prescription for Health in an Overtreated America (Get the book.)

"But governments, especially, are committed to 'evidence-based medicine', and reluctant to spend taxpayers' money on unregulated and unproven procedures. Thus, voices from within the major medical heterodoxies—particularly homeopathy, chiropractic, osteopathy, acupuncture, Ayurveda, 'traditional Chinese medicine', and herbal medicine—are calling for regulation or the legal right to self-regulate. And governments are debating the same issues, while increasing funding for 'scientific' research into the efficacy of heterodox practices (to the disgust of many in the biomedical community)." - Roberta Bivins, Alternative Medicine?: A History (Get the book.)

"Hannele Yki-Javrinen in an editorial in The Lancet in 2005 as being due to "the power of marketing over evidence-based medicine in guiding treatment practices." The number of prescriptions for these drugs for heart-failure patients has doubled over the past five years. A new glitazone, called Muraglitazar, which has been shown to increase the risk of death, heart attack, and stroke by more than twofold,3 has not been approved by the FDA. Another glitazone, called Rezulin, has been taken off the market because of lethal side effects related to liver damage." - J. Douglas Bremner, Before You Take that Pill: Why the Drug Industry May Be Bad for Your Health (Get the book.)

"THE MATTER OF PROOF Both current clinical science and regulatory policy are eagerly pursuing an approach to certainty described as "evidence based," despite frequently overlooked shortcomings in this approach as practiced [5, 6]. evidence-based medicine (EBM), even before it got that name, had typically been applied to evaluation of procedural or pharmacological interventions in individual patients, such as "Does radical mastectomy for breast cancer produce better outcomes than lumpectomy?" or "Do beta blockers improve survival after myocardial infarction?" - Ann M. Coulston and Carol J. Boushey, Nutrition in the Prevention and Treatment of Disease (Get the book.) "Evidence-based medicine and common sense: practical and ethical issues in clinical trials for osteoporosis. Future Rheumatol. 2, 104-110. 7. Roller, S. T., Voorhees, T., and Lunkenheimer, Jr., A. K. (2006). Obesity, food marketing and consumer litigation: threat or opportunity? Food Drug Law J 61, 419-444. 8. Heaney, R. P. (2005). Vitamin D: Role in the calcium economy. In "Vitamin D," 2nd ed. (D. Feldman, F. H. Glorieux, and J. W. Pike, Eds.), pp. 773-787. Academic Press, San Diego. 9. Shea, B., Wells, G, Cranney, A., Zytaruk, N., Robinson, V., Griffith, L., Ortiz, Z., Peterson, J." - Ann M. Coulston and Carol J. Boushey, Nutrition in the Prevention and Treatment of Disease (Get the book.)

"So much for evidence-based medicine. From my perspective, Pasternak was wrong. The study did not tempt me to think that statins don't work—it just made me think that tripling the number of people on statins doesn't provide any additional benefit. Dr. Pasternak was one of the original 14 authors of the 2001 cholesterol guidelines. He declared financial relationships with nine drug companies in the "financial disclosures" that accompanied his editorial in JAMA." - John Abramson, Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine (P.S.) (Get the book.) "In this era of modern, evidence-based medicine, how could so many women have been placed on drugs that turned out to be bad for their health? MEDICALIZING MENOPAUSE Menopause, the end of menstruation, is the second most significant biological transition in a woman's life, the first being the onset of menstruation. The high levels of reproductive hormones necessary for childbearing shift down to the lower levels needed during the post-reproductive part of a woman's life. In 1997, Dr." - John Abramson, Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine (P.S.) (Get the book.) "But not such a problem if the game is really hardball dressed up as evidence-based medicine. A strategic marketing consultant for the pharmaceutical industry was quoted in the British Medical Journal as saying, "So you've got one study that says yes, you should [use a diuretic], then starting the day after, you've got a $10 billion industry... and 55 promotional events .. . for an ACE inhibitor coming back in and saying 'Here's why my ACE inhibitor is safe and here's why you should be using this.' I mean, it's promotion. Can ALLHAT stand up to that?" Almost certainly not." - John Abramson, Overdosed America: The Broken Promise of American Medicine (P.S.) (Get the book.)

"The result is the spawning of yet another discipline devoted to making sense of all this output ?"evidence-based medicine," or ebm. Around the world, groups of investigators are sifting through all the evidence to sort the wheat from the chaff. Yes, there is chaff. Some trials were designed less well than others because nuances that improve design were unappreciated or ignored, or because of execution or even faults in data analysis. Yet it's not rational, or feasible, simply to rely on the most adequate trials for diagnosis and treatment." - Nortin M. Hadler MD, Worried Sick: A Prescription for Health in an Overtreated America (Get the book.) "Gerstein of McMaster University, the North American epicenter of evidence-based medicine. In an editorial in the august Annals of Internal Medicine, Gerstein declares "Potential Financial Conflicts of Interest" in his business relationships with Aventis, Lilly, and Novo Nordisk ?all pharmaceutical firms heavily committed to purveying agents for the treatment of type 2 diabetes. Monitoring blood sugar and/or hemoglobin Aic and treating when "abnormal" became the mantra of the American Diabetes Association in 2006." - Nortin M. Hadler MD, Worried Sick: A Prescription for Health in an Overtreated America (Get the book.)

"Once again we see that the physician's routine practice and local culture are relatively immune to scientific, evidence-based medicine. The medical literature on the effectiveness of mammograms is confusing and contradictory. Official recommendations change often. "Is a woman less likely to die of breast cancer if she starts screening while she is in her forties?"46 This is the question posed by the Canadian National Breast Screening Study. Their answer: Women who received annual mammographies (along with self and clinical breast exams) did not live longer than those who did not." - Gerald E. Markle and Frances B. McCrea, What If Medicine Disappeared? (Get the book.)

"David Eddy, a heart surgeon turned mathematician turned health care economist and a leader in the evidence-based medicine movement, estimates that as little as 15 percent of what doctors do is backed up by valid evidence. What's the best treatment for chronic sinusitis? Surgery? Antibiotics? Nobody really knows. How well do fertility treatments really work? (Probably not as well as fertility clinics advertise.) What's the most effective way to bring down skyrocketing rates of diabetes? New drugs? Screening people for high blood sugar? Sending patients to weight-loss clinics?" - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.) "It doesn't much matter which way a hospital and its affiliated physicians want to organize themselves, as long as they begin working as a cooperative group that uses valid evidence-based medicine. It's possible to imagine that one day, integrated physician-hospital systems will compete with one another for patients on the basis of the quality of care they deliver and their efficiency. The VHA, if it expanded eligibility to all veterans, would be one place among many that veterans could choose." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.)

"Such is the fate of several of the sentinel ideas discussed in this volume; "paradigm shift" and "evidence-based medicine" are examples of the hackneyed, and "refutationist" is a candidate. The concepts remain important nonetheless. Medicalization is useful, despite its negative connotation, to denote the crossing of boundaries that society had considered or still considers the purview of medicine. It is useful in critiquing pharmaceutical marketing practice, particularly direct-to-consumer marketing, for example (Metzl 2007)." - Nortin M. Hadler MD, Worried Sick: A Prescription for Health in an Overtreated America (Get the book.)

"All the evidence suggests that these groups are more likely than doctors in solo practice or small groups to use evidence-based medicine and employ information technology to deliver more-effective care. Another model is the hospital chain that employs physicians. Intermountain Healthcare owns twenty-one hospitals and clinics and employs twenty-one thousand people, including its doctors. If every hospital in America achieved the same level of efficiency in caring for the chronically ill as Intermountain, Medicare would save more than ten billion dollars a year." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.) "By the 1990s, progressive doctors were talking about a new movement called "evidence-based medicine," but well into the twenty-first century, much of what doctors do remains evidence-free. Medicine is both an art and a science, they say, the art being the intuition and informed guesswork they apply in the absence of clear symptoms or good data for what treatments work best. Deans of medical schools often tell graduating doctors that half of what they have learned in the past four years is wrong—but nobody knows which half." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.)

"The commitment to evidence-based medicine is relatively new. In some of its most ardent practitioners, this commitment can result in clear choices that sometimes may have tragic results. Tom Chalmers was one of the first physicians, along with Archie Cochrane, to urge the scientific study of medical procedures and drugs.20 He was the man Dr. Love and I turned to when we wrote our article for JAMA. We quoted his insistence that research alone would provide the only guidance on how to design better medicine." - Devra Davis, The Secret History of the War on Cancer (Get the book.)

"All the evidence suggests that these groups are more likely than doctors in solo practice or small groups to use evidence-based medicine and employ information technology to deliver more-effective care. Another model is the hospital chain that employs physicians. Intermountain Healthcare owns twenty-one hospitals and clinics and employs twenty-one thousand people, including its doctors. If every hospital in America achieved the same level of efficiency in caring for the chronically ill as Intermountain, Medicare would save more than ten billion dollars a year." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.) "By the 1990s, progressive doctors were talking about a new movement called "evidence-based medicine," but well into the twenty-first century, much of what doctors do remains evidence-free. Medicine is both an art and a science, they say, the art being the intuition and informed guesswork they apply in the absence of clear symptoms or good data for what treatments work best. Deans of medical schools often tell graduating doctors that half of what they have learned in the past four years is wrong—but nobody knows which half." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.) "Such small practices have a hard time purchasing IT, but they also are less likely than larger, multispe-cialty practices to use evidence-based medicine. Getting them to integrate the care of the chronically ill, the way the doctors in Bellingham, Washington, have learned to do would mean restructuring the way they are paid. What we really want doctors to do is start behaving less like independent businesses and more like physicians in integrated health care plans like the VHA, Group Health, and the Mayo Clinic." - Shannon Brownlee, Overtreated: Why Too Much Medicine Is Making Us Sicker and Poorer (Get the book.)

"This is a scientific approach, what some people call evidence-based medicine. Doctors at the center strive to correct nutrient deficiencies and imbalances that contribute to prediabetes, diabetes, overweight, and many other health problems. (In contrast, more conventional drug therapies tend to mask, but not correct, signs of vitamin and mineral deficiencies.) Following this approach, we treat patients appropriately, neither overtreating nor undertreating them. Follow-up testing tracks changes in nutrient levels." - Jack Challem, Stop Prediabetes Now: The Ultimate Plan to Lose Weight and Prevent Diabetes (Get the book.)

"After all, it's all about "evidence-based medicine," right? It is if you don't believe in good science. Because drug companies seem to have conveniently forgotten what good science means anymore. Today, it's not about discovering some new scientific truth, it's about distorting science to sell more products. To call it junk science is an understatement. Big Pharma's trespasses into scientific fraud go way beyond mere junk science." - Mike Adams, Natural Health Solutions (Get the book.)

"This is called evidence-based medicine. What does this mean? In medicine, we try to determine whether a drug or a procedure works by comparing it to a placebo control or, perhaps, another treatment that has been proven to work, an active control. A placebo treatment can be as a comparison of effectiveness, or a new treatment could be measured for effectiveness against a standard one. This necessitates that the study in which the treatment is tested be designed in a way that will not influence the results and that enough people participate in the study so the results can be meaningful." - John E. Sarno, M.D., The Divided Mind: The Epidemic of Mindbody Disorders (Get the book.) "How can we apply the standards of evidence-based medicine in this situation? Is it possible to do better in studying this approach than has been done? It is difficult because psychological treatments do not easily lend themselves to the ideal clinical trial methodology. How can we conduct studies to see if psychological approaches can cure this condition? Patients with TMS must be psychologically open to the diagnosis to improve. They must be ready to renounce the idea that their cure is to be found in structural or chemical means." - John E. Sarno, M.D., The Divided Mind: The Epidemic of Mindbody Disorders (Get the book.)

page 1 of 3 | Next ->

FAIR USE NOTICE: The research quoted here is provided under the protection of Fair Use provisions and published by the 501(c)3 non-profit Consumer Wellness Center for the purposes of public comment and education. Authors / publishers may submit books for consideration of inclusion here.

TERMS OF USE: Read full terms of use. Citations of text from NaturalPedia must include: 1) Full credit to the original author and book title. 2) Secondary credit to the Natural News Naturalpedia as a research resource and a link to www.NaturalPedia.com

This unique compilation of research is copyright (c) 2008, 2009 by the non-profit Consumer Wellness Center.

ABOUT THE CREATOR OF NATURALPEDIA: Mike Adams, the creator of NaturalPedia, is the editor of NaturalNews.com, the internet's top natural health news site, creator of the Honest Food Guide (www.HonestFoodGuide.org), a free downloadable consumer food guide based on natural health principles, author of Grocery Warning, The 7 Laws of Nutrition, Natural Health Solutions, and many other books available at www.TruthPublishing.com, creator of the earth-friendly EcoLEDs company (www.EcoLEDs.com) that manufactures energy-efficient LED lighting products, founder of Arial Software (www.ArialSoftware.com), a permission e-mail technology company, creator of the CounterThink Cartoon series (www.NaturalNews.com/index-cartoons.html) and author of over 1,500 articles, interviews, special reports and reference guides available at www.NaturalNews.com. Adams' personal philosophy and health statistics are available at www.HealthRanger.org.